The ruthless machinery of Manchester United continues to churn, with reports emerging that the club hierarchy is set to snub Michael Carrick for the permanent managerial role, despite his flawless start. The interim boss has steadied the ship, but the allure of a "superstar" manager appears to be blinding the board to the talent already in the dugout.

It is a classic United paradox: a club desperate for stability yet addicted to the dopamine hit of a big-name signing. Carrick, a club legend who knows the DNA of Old Trafford better than anyone, has delivered results that arguably eclipse the tenures of his predecessors. Yet, the ghost of mediocrity haunts the decision-makers, pushing them toward established European heavyweights like Thomas Tuchel or Roberto De Zerbi, rather than trusting the quiet competence of their own man.

The Unbeaten Interim

Carrick’s audition has been nothing short of spectacular.Since taking over from Ruben Amorim, he has guided the Red Devils back into the top four conversation, remaining unbeaten in his first five games. His tactical acumen was on full display in victories against Manchester City and Arsenal—results that usually guarantee a long-term contract.

• The West Ham Stumble: The only blemish, if it can be called that, was a gritty draw against West Ham on Tuesday. A late Benjamin Sesko goal salvaged a point, proving that even under Carrick, the team has the "Fergie Time" resilience.
• The Board’s Vision: Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the INEOS group are reportedly seeking a "proven winner" with a global profile. Tuchel, formerly of Chelsea and Bayern, fits this mold perfectly, while Carrick is seen as a riskier, sentimental choice.

The Gary Neville Warning

Former captain Gary Neville has voiced what many fans are thinking: the grass isn`t always greener. He warned that overlooking Carrick for a "big name" could be a repetition of past mistakes. However, Neville also conceded that Carrick might reject the job himself to protect his legacy, understanding the poisoned chalice that the United hot seat has become.

As the summer approaches, the decision will define the Ratcliffe era. Will they gamble on the glitz of Tuchel, or reward the substance of Carrick? For now, the interim boss keeps winning, making the board’s impending snub look more foolish with every three points.